Georgia high court: DUI test refusal can't be used in court

March 6, 2019

by Associated Press

Tuesday, February 19th 2019

The high court unanimously agreed the provision violated the Georgia Constitution's protection against self-incrimination.. Photo by Ashleigh Jackson - KOMU - CC BY 2.0


ATLANTA — A driver's refusal to submit to a breath test cannot be used as evidence in a criminal trial for driving under the influence, Georgia's Supreme Court ruled Monday, throwing out that part of the state's DUI laws as unconstitutional.

The high court unanimously agreed the provision violated the Georgia Constitution's protection against self-incrimination.

Justice Nels S.D. Peterson, in the ruling, acknowledged the Supreme Court's decision could make it more difficult to prosecute DUI offenses. But Peterson added: "The right to be free from compelled self-incrimination does not wax or wane based on the severity of a defendant's alleged crimes."

The decision came in a case where a driver challenged a DUI arrest in Clarke County. Andrea Elliott refused to submit to a breath test when she was arrested in August 2015, and prosecutors sought to use that refusal against her in a criminal trial, according to the Supreme Court ruling.

Her lawyer argued the admission of that evidence at trial would violate her constitutional rights against self-incrimination. A lower court disagreed, and Elliott appealed the decision to the Georgia Supreme Court, which ruled in her favor Monday.

"This Court cannot change the Georgia Constitution, even if we believe there may be good policy reasons for doing so; only the General Assembly and the people of Georgia may do that. And this Court cannot rewrite statutes," Peterson wrote in the opinion.

In a concurring opinion, Justice Michael P. Boggs noted the scope of the ruling was limited to circumstances involving a criminal proceeding. He wrote that a driver's refusal to take a breath test still could be used in an administrative proceeding for a driver's license suspension.

Read the full ruling below:


RULING: Georgia high court:... by on Scribd


Please reload

Featured Posts

A criminal arrest can be emotionally devastating. You do not have to face the criminal allegations alone. We are here to help.

If you are charged with...

Criminal charges can be life changing.

March 6, 2019

Please reload

Recent Posts
Please reload

Please reload

Search By Tags

I'm busy working on my blog posts. Watch this space!

Please reload

© 2018 by Albert III & Associates LLC. Proudly created by DE-MAN Images

  • Facebook Clean
  • Twitter Clean
  • LinkedIn Clean